School Girl Classic vs Rebel

Ally has a huge crush on the new guy in school! He is so handsome and dreamy, and very smart too, he is the English club's best student. On top of all this, he loves punk-rock music and plays the guitar. Ally is also in the English club and they have a reunion today. She wonders if he will sit next to her as the last time. She really wants to impress him, so she needs to look absolutely fabulous today. But how should she dress? Wearing something classic and chic would be a good idea, but a rebel outfit might also work. What do you think? Create both looks for Ally and see which one looks better.